Is God a seizure?
Thursday, March 22nd, 2007I have discovered that John Watson at the University of Sydney has coined the term ‘neurotheology’ for the branch of ’science’ that is trying to establish that religious experiences are simply a type of epileptic seizure. In particular, they point at temporal lobe epilepsy (the type that I have) as being the ‘logical explanation’ for those that feel the presence of God. They figured this out after putting Carmelite nuns into MRI scanners, while the nuns were praying.
I actually find this insulting - on two accounts. Firstly by claiming that religion is no more than a brain condition, it implies that religion can be ‘cured’ with the same anticonvulsants that are currently making my life hell. Secondly it implies that it is more important to ‘disprove’ religion than it is to find cures for epilepsy.
I wanted to let you know that, as somebody with the form of epilepsy that is implicated in all this, I utterly disagree with the hypotheses and particularly the ethics behind ‘neurotheology’.
Please don’t believe everything that so-called ’scientists’ come up with - sometimes, one needs to question their motivation..
I particularly wanted to thank BB1968, Gallaman and Bluesplaya at this point, for keeping me sane recently.






Leave Comment