I have to confess I have a love-hate relationship with protein shakes. On the one hand, they’re great for getting that extra boost when you wanna pack on some muscle. On the other hand, if you take it to the extreme like I did many years ago, well… it ain’t pretty.
Back in ‘97, I was doing a radio morning show and we did a promotion with a local gym and bodybuilding company where me and my morning girl would start a nutrition/exercise program and keep our listeners updated on our progress. Great. I was excited because we’d get to workout with these personal trainers and I needed the motivation. So we set up a program, the guys give us a bunch of free supplements (their brand of course) and tell us what to eat and when. We met them at the gym a few days a week and powered through some pretty intense workouts. In fact, on my first day, the trainer asked me what I normally used when doing biceps curls. At the time, its was only about 25 lbs. He told me to pick up the 50’s and go for it. I cried. He slapped me, and I was OK.
Anyway, obviously the nutrition was a big part of the program. Well, being in radio, I didn’t have a lot of time on my hands to formulate a plan of attack and consume tons of food. So, brilliantly, I figured I could replace several meals a day with protein shakes. No biggie - lotsa people do it. As the weeks went by, I started getting bigger and more ripped. In fact, those were the most incredible results I’ve ever had (of course like an idiot I never thought to have pictures taken). Loving the results, I increased the amount of protein I was drinking, until towards the end I was taking in a 1,000-calorie shake THREE times a day. Now, for lotsa huge bodybuilders, that may be nothing. But for a smaller guy like me, I might as well have had a feeding tube jacked in to my stomach pumping protein 24/7. It was a recipe for disaster.
After about 3-4 weeks of these shakes - and understand that I wasn’t drinking NEARLY enough water or eating much real food at all - I started feeling tired more often. One morning after drinking my shake, I felt like I had just runa marathon - I had to literally sit down in a chair during our morning show I was that drained. Wasn’t sure if I was getting sick or what, so I went another day or so before realizing something was wrong. Saw a doctor and told him what was going on, and he immediately told me I was doing WAY too much protein. He mentioned something called "renal failiure" and I thought "Great - my ass is gonna fall off." Actually, renal failure means a major problem with your kidneys, and mine were on the brink of shutting down. In fact, I had taken in SO much protein that my entire digestive system went haywire.
The prescription: I had to literally RE-TRAIN my digestive system how to work properly. For several onths, I was eating nothing but applesauce and white rice. It was NOT a pleasant experience, especially having to gather my own - look away now if you’re squeamish, you’ve been warned - *stool* sample once a week to have the labs examine it. I don’t know about you, but having to fish my own crap out of a toilet isn’t something that’s high on my list of fun things to do.
Needless to say, I learned a hard lesson from that experience, and I’m lucky and grateful I didn’t end up in a wooden box. For YEARS after that, I didn’t touch protein, and barely flirted with exercise.
NOW, I’m smarter and more realistic. I actually just started taking a protein shake on a DAILY basis earlier this year, and I was very cautious about it. Of course, this time around, I’m not loading up the shake with extra maltodextrin and tons of god-knows-what supplements that those trainers handed me to dump in there. I started out with half a shake a day, and am now drinking one (and ONLY one) per day, along with about 1 gallon of water a day and a proper nutrition strategy that consists of actually eating FOOD. The results have been great.
Protein is a valuable supplement to a good nutritional strategy, but that’s all it is - a SUPPLEMENT to the lean food you should be eating as a mainstay in order to achieve the results you want.
I should’ve called this blog WHAT NOT TO DO TO BE HEALTHY, cuz I’ve got lots more stories!
View all comments | Leave Comment